Blog

“What if I told you your biggest profit leak is not your ad spend, your fees, or your shipping… it is your inventory sync?”

You are not losing sleep because your listings are ugly. You are losing sleep because Amazon sold 27 units that eBay thought did not exist, or because you got an out-of-stock ding that killed your Buy Box share for a week. Inventory that is not synced costs you in oversells, canceled orders, stockouts, and dead cash on shelves.

Here is the blunt truth:
You do not need a fancy new marketplace. You need a single source of truth for your stock, wired into Amazon and eBay with rules that protect you from latency and human error. One central inventory brain, minimal manual touches, and clear timing rules for every sync event.

That is what we are going to build.

—

Why inventory chaos is draining your profit

If you sell the same SKU on Amazon and eBay, you are doing financial surgery with a rusty knife if your inventory is not tightly synced.

If your inventory is wrong, your profit numbers are a lie, your ad decisions are distorted, and your Buy Box risk jumps every time you get an out-of-stock cancellation.

You do not just lose money when you oversell. You also lose ranking and trust. On Amazon, a string of cancellations can push you off the Buy Box and bury you. On eBay, “out of stock” cancellations crush your seller rating and lower your placement.

Here is how that chaos usually starts:

Problem	What you see	What is actually happening
Overselling	Orders you cannot fulfill	Inventory changed in one channel, not the other
Stockouts	Listings going to zero too early	Buffers mis-set or listing qty throttled too hard
Phantom stock	System shows stock, bin is empty	Returns, damages, or mis-picks not feeding back to the master
Cash drag	Too much stock in low-velocity SKUs	No clear data on what actually sells where and how fast

You do not fix this with more spreadsheets or more VAs.
You fix it by treating inventory like code: one master, version control, and strict rules for what can change it.

Inventory should have one system of record. Every other system is a client. Clients never change stock; they only request or consume it.

So your job is to decide: what is the master, and how does Amazon and eBay talk to it?

—

Choosing your “source of truth” for stock

You have three practical models for inventory sync across Amazon and eBay:

• Amazon (FBA) as source of truth
• A third-party inventory or order management system as source of truth
• Your own database or app as source of truth

Let us walk through each with a clear lens: which one makes you more money for the least complexity.

Model 1: Using Amazon (FBA) as your master

If you are mostly FBA and you mirror those SKUs to eBay, Amazon stock can be your inventory brain. You pull FBA available quantity, apply a safety buffer, and push that to eBay.

This works best when:

– Most units sit at Amazon, not your own warehouse
– eBay sales are lower volume and more like a secondary outlet
– You do not need very detailed warehouse tracking beyond what Amazon offers

Flow looks like this:

1. Amazon updates FBA quantity (receipts, sales, returns).
2. Your system reads it on a schedule (via API or a tool).
3. You apply a rule: “List up to X units on eBay, never more than FBA available minus buffer.”
4. eBay listing quantity is updated.

If 90% of your sales volume lives on Amazon, do not over-engineer a heavy inventory layer. Let Amazon be the spine and let eBay follow.

The risk: latency.
If you only pull data every 15 or 30 minutes during peak time, your eBay stock can be wrong for a while. You can limit this problem with strict listing caps and buffers, but it is not perfect.

You are trading some risk for speed and simplicity.

Model 2: Third-party inventory system as master

This is where most serious multichannel sellers land. A SaaS tool sits in the middle and connects to:

– Amazon (FBA and FBM)
– eBay
– Maybe your own site (Shopify, WooCommerce, etc.)
– Your warehouse, 3PL, or POS

This tool holds the true quantity for each SKU and location. Amazon and eBay both read from it and write orders back to it.

Use this model when:

– You have meaningful volume on both Amazon and eBay
– You stock the same SKU in more than one place (for example FBA + your own warehouse)
– You want clear reporting on total stock, sell-through, and replenishment

Typical flow:

1. You receive 500 units into your warehouse. Warehouse stock is updated in the inventory system.
2. System applies rules: for example, 300 units are “available to sell” across channels; 200 are reserved for wholesale or future batches.
3. It pushes available stock to Amazon FBM and eBay using independent buffers.
4. Orders from Amazon and eBay feed back in real time and subtract from the same pool.
5. The system applies order priority rules (for example, FBA where possible, then warehouse).

If Amazon and eBay do not see the same inventory pool at the same time, you do not have multichannel. You have two separate stores stealing stock from each other.

The risk here is cost and complexity.
You are now dependent on a SaaS vendor, their API limits, and their uptime. You must design your sync rules cleanly or it will turn into a mess.

But for any seller pushing volume across both channels, this is the most stable approach.

Model 3: Your own database as master

If you run your own custom stack, you may want full control. In that case, your own database or app is the brain.

You store:

– Product catalog and SKU mapping
– Virtual inventory pools
– Per-channel rules and buffers
– Audit logs for every stock change

Then you talk directly to Amazon MWS/SP-API and eBay APIs.

Choose this route if:

– You have dev resources, and this sync is strategic, not a side task
– You need logic that SaaS tools do not support (complex bundles, multi-warehouse rules, custom pricing tiers)
– You want to avoid SaaS limits and build your own schedule, throttling, and monitoring

This can make you a lot of money if you do it right, because you can tune inventory exposure around margins, ad performance, and seasonality. But it is real engineering work, not a weekend project.

If you do not have a developer who owns this problem long term, do not build your own. Buy something and customize around it.

—

Mapping SKUs correctly across Amazon and eBay

You cannot sync what you cannot identify. Most inventory nightmares start with bad SKU mapping.

You should treat SKU as the atomic unit in your system, even if channel identifiers differ.

Here is what each channel gives you:

Platform	Identifier types	What you control
Amazon	ASIN, FNSKU, Seller SKU	Seller SKU, listing status, fulfillment (FBA/FBM)
eBay	Item ID, Custom SKU, Variant IDs	Custom SKU, variations, listing quantity

Your system needs a stable “internal SKU” that never changes. Then you map:

– Internal SKU -> Amazon Seller SKU
– Internal SKU -> eBay custom SKU (and variation ID where needed)

Rules that keep you sane:

1. Never use ASIN or eBay Item ID as your master key. These can change or be reused.
2. Keep the same SKU string across platforms wherever you can. If that is not possible, map it explicitly in your inventory system.
3. Handle bundles and kits as separate virtual SKUs that link back to component SKUs.

If two listings on different channels share the same physical units, they must share the same internal SKU. Otherwise you will double count stock forever.

For bundles (for example a “2-pack” on eBay that uses the same units as single packs on Amazon), your logic must reduce base stock based on bundle sales.
If one bundle sells, stock reduces by 2 at the component level. Then your system recalculates how many bundles and singles you can still sell.

This is where cheap systems break. They treat every listing as separate instead of seeing the shared components. If you sell a lot of multipacks or kits, do not skip this.

—

Designing your sync logic: timing, buffers, and risk

Once your master and SKU mapping are clear, you need clear logic for when and how stock changes.

You are balancing:

– Sales speed
– API limits
– Risk of oversell
– Risk of leaving money on the table with too large a buffer

Pull and push frequencies

You have two directions of movement:

– Pull: You read orders and stock changes from Amazon and eBay.
– Push: You send updated quantities back to those platforms.

If your tool or system supports near real time, push for it. If not, you control the schedule.

Simple rule of thumb:

Volume situation	Recommended sync cycle
Low volume, stable items	Every 15 minutes
Medium volume, standard catalog	Every 5 minutes
High volume, flash deals, seasonal spikes	Real time or sub 2-minute cycles

If you sell 100+ units per hour of a SKU, 15-minute syncs are not “slow”. They are reckless.

You also need event-based syncs:

– When an order is placed
– When a return hits
– When you receive a shipment into stock
– When you manually adjust stock after a count

Each of these events should trigger a stock update for affected SKUs right away, not just wait for the next batch.

Stock buffers: your safety net against oversell

A buffer is the number of units you “hide” from a marketplace to protect against sync lag and miscounts.

Example:
You have 100 units in your master. You set:

– Amazon buffer: 5
– eBay buffer: 5

So each channel only ever sees 95 units as “available”. If both drain quickly, you still have a 5-unit cushion to avoid hard stockouts while sync catches up.

You can also use percentage rules:

– Show only 70 percent of real stock on eBay
– Show only 80 percent on Amazon FBM
– Show full stock for FBA (because Amazon controls that portion)

This is not guesswork.
You look at your typical volume and your sync delay, then choose conservative buffers and trim down over time.

If you are overselling a lot, your buffer is too small or your sync is too slow.
If you always end up with leftover inventory at the end of a season, your buffer is probably too aggressive.

Channel priority rules

You should not treat all channels equally. Some SKUs will be more valuable on Amazon than on eBay or vice versa. You can bake this into your inventory allocation.

Common rules:

– Always protect some stock for Amazon FBA replenishment.
– Give Amazon priority over eBay for fast-moving SKUs with better margins.
– Cap eBay quantity to a hard maximum (for example no more than 20 units active).

You can express this as:

– A reserved quantity per channel
– A priority ranking: if total stock is low, eBay quantity gets cut first

Your aim is to sell the last units of a SKU on the channel that gives you the most profit and ranking benefit, not the one that happens to sync a few seconds faster.

—

Handling FBA, FBM, and warehouse stock together

Many sellers trip when they mix FBA and FBM inventory for the same SKU, then throw eBay into the mix. If you do not plan this well, you either double count stock or hide units that you could sell.

Separate your inventory buckets

You should track at least these buckets per SKU:

– FBA stock (Amazon fulfillment centers)
– Local warehouse or 3PL stock
– Inbound stock (on the way, not yet sellable)
– Reserved stock (for bundles, promotions, B2B, or internal use)

Only some of these are “available to sell.”
Your master must define that clearly.

Example layout:

Bucket	Quantity	Sellable on Amazon	Sellable on eBay
FBA	300	Yes (FBA)	No (unless you ship multi-channel from FBA)
Warehouse	200	Yes (FBM)	Yes
Inbound	100	No	No
Reserved	50	No	No

So your “available to sell” might be:

– Amazon FBA: 300
– Amazon FBM: some portion of the 200 warehouse units
– eBay: some portion of the same 200 warehouse units

Your system must make sure that FBA units are not double counted as warehouse units. Many small tools mistake FBA inbound for general stock and expose it to other channels.

Using FBA to fulfill eBay orders

You can ship marketplace orders from FBA (multi-channel fulfillment or “MCF”). That means your eBay orders can eat into FBA stock.

If you do this, your master must treat FBA stock as shared between Amazon and eBay. Otherwise, you will oversell quickly.

Key rules:

1. FBA stock is one pool, not two.
2. Every eBay order that you fulfill via FBA must subtract from FBA available units in your master.
3. Adjust buffers to respect FBA lead times and MCF delays.

If you push this hard, watch your FBA storage fees and inbound timing. There is a point where feeding eBay too aggressively from FBA will hurt margin.

If you are using FBA to fulfill other channels, treat FBA as a shared warehouse, not a channel-specific silo.

—

Dealing with returns, cancellations, and mistakes

Sales change stock in one direction. Returns and cancellations change it in the other direction. If you get this wrong, your numbers drift and your reports become fiction.

Marketplace returns

When a buyer returns on Amazon or eBay, two things may happen:

– Items are resellable
– Items are damaged or missing

You must handle both:

1. Pull return events through the API or your tool.
2. If the marketplace marks items as “sellable”, add them back to the correct bucket (FBA or warehouse).
3. If items are not sellable, they should not re-enter your available stock. Track them in a “damaged” bucket instead.

Many sellers lazily add all returns back. That inflates stock and guarantees oversell later.

Order cancellations and payment failures

If an order is canceled before shipment or the payment fails, stock should be released.

Your logic:

– When order moves from “pending” to “canceled”, restore stock to the same bucket it came from.
– If you already picked and packed the item, but did not ship, decide if you put it back into stock or hold it in a separate bin. Your system should mirror that physical decision.

You do not have an inventory problem in the system if your physical process in the warehouse is random. Software cannot fix bins that nobody respects.

—

Reducing manual work without losing control

You want automation, but you also want control. The trick is to decide which actions the system can take alone, and which ones require your review.

What you should automate

– Stock updates between master and marketplaces
– Buffers and per-channel quantity rules
– Status changes from orders (new, picked, shipped) that affect stock
– Routine reports: low stock alerts, high-velocity SKUs, aging stock

Once those are in place, you free your team from babysitting counts. They can focus on sourcing, content, and pricing.

What you should keep under manual review

– Major stock adjustments after cycle counts
– New bundle definitions and bundle rules
– Channel priority changes for high-value SKUs
– Any rule that can take a SKU to zero on a channel

You can still use a system to stage these changes, but you want human approval. One wrong mapping or rule can hide your top product for days.

—

Monitoring: catching sync issues before they hurt sales

If you assume your inventory sync always works, it will fail when it hurts most, like during Q4 or a promotion.

You need health checks.

Key checks and alerts

Set up checks for:

– SKUs where marketplace quantity does not match master quantity pattern (after buffer)
– SKUs with rapid stock swings that do not match order volume
– SKUs with repeated oversell or frequent “order cannot be fulfilled” flags
– Listings that consistently sit at zero while you have stock in the warehouse

Simple practice:

– Once a day, pull a snapshot from Amazon and eBay and compare against your master for a subset of SKUs.
– Once a week, run a full audit for all active SKUs and flag discrepancies.

Good inventory sync is not set-and-forget. It is a system you watch with small, pointed alarms before it goes off the rails.

You can have your developer script these checks, or use your inventory tool if it supports reporting. If your tool cannot give you this visibility, that is a warning sign.

—

How smart inventory sync improves SEO and conversion

Inventory sync is not just about not getting banned. It also affects how often you are shown and how often people convert when they land on your listings.

Amazon and eBay visibility effects

Search ranking on these platforms favors:

– High in-stock rate
– Low cancellation rate
– Strong conversion history

If you frequently run out of stock, or cancel often, your listings slide down. When they do show, low available quantity can hurt buyer confidence.

Example:

– A buyer sees “Only 1 left in stock” and wonders if you are a real seller or a hobbyist.
– eBay shows “Limited quantity” all the time and shoppers choose a competitor with clear stock.

By keeping stable stock levels with smaller but steady buffers, you:

– Show up more often
– Convert more views into sales
– Waste less ad spend on listings that cannot fulfill

SEO for your own site

If your own ecommerce site pulls from the same inventory pool, stock accuracy affects:

– Your product sitemap (products that are always out of stock can be de-prioritized)
– Your conversion paths (ranking pages that end in an “out of stock” dead end)

A strong master inventory lets you:

– Hide permanently dead products cleanly
– Keep back-in-stock notifications honest
– Route ad traffic to variants or bundles that are actually sellable

This is how inventory sync connects directly to your SEO and paid strategy: you reduce wasted clicks and send shoppers only to viable offers.

—

Practical build: what to actually do next

If you want to get this live instead of just nodding at the ideas, you need a pragmatic build path.

Step 1: Decide your master and write it down

Pick one:

– Amazon FBA as master, with eBay following
– Third-party SaaS inventory system
– Your own app or database

Write a one-page spec:

– What holds the true stock quantity
– Which channels read from it
– Which actions can modify it (orders, returns, receipts, manual adjustments)

If your answer is “various spreadsheets” or “our VA keeps track,” then your first move is to stop adding channels until you fix this.

Step 2: Clean your SKU mapping

Export:

– All Amazon SKUs with ASINs
– All eBay listings with custom SKUs and item IDs
– Your internal product list

Put them in a single table and resolve:

– Duplicates
– Missing SKUs
– Wrong matches

Then set your rule for new products: no new listing goes live without a mapped internal SKU.

Step 3: Set conservative buffers and sync intervals

Start safe:

– Buffers of 5 to 10 units or 20 percent of stock, whichever is higher, on the secondary channel
– Sync intervals no longer than 5 minutes for order pulls
– Immediate event-based updates on order creation and shipment

Watch oversells and excess stock over a few weeks, then adjust.

Step 4: Define channel priority for key SKUs

Pick your top 20 revenue SKUs.

For each, decide:

– Which channel gets priority if stock goes low
– Whether to cap quantity on eBay
– Whether to reserve stock for FBA replenishment

Put these rules into your system as explicit settings, not as ideas in your head.

Step 5: Add monitoring and alerts

Set up at least:

– A daily discrepancy report between master and Amazon/eBay
– An alert for any SKU oversold more than N times in a week
– A list of SKUs that have been at zero on Amazon or eBay for more than X days while stock exists

Then schedule someone to actually review these alerts.

—

If you treat inventory sync as a core profit lever, not just admin, you will see three things happen:

– Fewer support tickets and cancellations
– More stable sales ranks and buy box percentage
– Higher confidence in your own numbers, which feeds better ad and purchasing decisions

You do not need another marketplace. You need one clean inventory brain, feeding Amazon and eBay with rules that match how you really sell.